Australia’s international standing at risk from harsh politicking

August 16, 2013

When this increasingly adolescent election is over, the land of the fair go will have cemented its new reputation internationally as the land of the ”go away”.

Like a harrumphing teenager who stomps to his room intent on making a difficult world non-existent, Australia’s mainstream parties are showing they know how to slam a door for dramatic impact.

And they know too, that tantrums don’t have to be based on much. In some cases, the tantrum itself is the object – a desperate plea for attention.

Advertisement

In the latest unpleasant development in the asylum wars, the Coalition has moved to again out-shout Labor’s zero-resettlement boats policy built around Papua New Guinea.

The opposition’s Scott Morrison is not one to take a hollering lying down.

Not for him the quiet satisfaction of knowing the Coalition had won the argument on boats causing a total Labor capitulation.

Indeed, that just brought a new political problem – that the boats may well stop coming.

Labor’s belated entry to the immigration ”Fight Club”, has caused panic and a series of reinforcements to the Coalition’s already comprehensive asylum-seeker response.

First the policy was quasi-militarised with a three-star general put in charge.

Then, it was buttressed with a 2000-strong tent city on Nauru, just in case.

Now it is to be retro-fitted with a zero citizenship rule applying to any poor wretch not already safely in when the Coalition comes to power.

The public policy grounds for this remain unclear. After all, what will it actually achieve beyond the harsh signal it sends out?

But then, this is not about signals, least not external ones anyway.

Rather, it is aimed at xenophobic voters whose shaky grasp of arithmetic has them quaking over the absorption of a group of people – many of whom are already located in the community.

Australia was a founding member of the United Nations and has forged a proud reputation as an upholder of international law, and the promotion of democracy and civilisation.

That reputation is at risk from a harsh domestic political culture which is stroppy, self-indulgent, and deaf to rational argument.

Source: http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/federal-election-2013/australias-international-standing-at-risk-from-harsh-politicking-20130815-2rzp8.html#ixzz2c9WqohlO

2 Comments

Filed under Analysis, Asylum Policy

2 responses to “Australia’s international standing at risk from harsh politicking

  1. Not a lot to argue against there. Well written.

  2. Hermes

    By affording people a ‘fair go’ we should never allow our country’s political leaders to descend into forelock tugging. The substantive facts are these: Australia is a sovereign nation with enforceable customs and immigration laws, that which includes national border security and control.
    A democratically elected Federal Government of Australia, first and foremost, has a duty of care to its own citizens, above all else.
    Australia is ‘our’ country, and we will decide who comes here – not people smugglers or self selecting asylum seekers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s