Boat tragedy claims 33 asylum seekers

November 25, 2012

Michael Bachelard

Michael Bachelard

Indonesia Correspondent for Fairfax Media

Survivor Habib Ullah is now at Kuningan Immigration detention centre, in Jakarta.Survivor Habib Ullah is now at Kuningan Immigration detention centre, in Jakarta.

ANOTHER 33 would-be asylum seekers have drowned on their way to Christmas Island in a boat tragedy that would have gone unreported if one man had not survived.

Habib Ullah, 22, has told Fairfax Media how he survived three days in the water while watching his shipmates, all ethnic Hazara men from Afghanistan and Pakistan, drown one by one.

Mr Ullah said that, during the ordeal, the men had seen two or three passing vessels, including an oil tanker and a container ship, which had not stopped to help. He was convinced the crew of the container ship saw them.

Habib Ullah aboard the boat that rescued him.Habib Ullah aboard the boat that rescued him.

Alone and on the verge of death, Mr Ullah was finally picked up by a passing Indonesian fishing boat and brought to Jakarta.


The Australian Maritime Safety Authority and the Indonesian search and rescue agency Basarnas have separately confirmed that they have no record of the vessel.

But Mr Ullah, who is now in immigration detention in Jakarta, has been overwhelmed by phone calls and visits from distressed relatives from Australia, as well as Pakistan and Afghanistan, who have heard nothing from their loved ones and are begging him for details.

Mr Ullah, who grew up in Pakistan but whose family is from Afghanistan, paid $US5500 ($A5295) to a people smuggler known as Sikander on the basis of gossip among refugees in Indonesia that ”he succeeded in taking many boats” to Australia.

The men set sail towards Christmas Island in the early hours of October 26, but after about 13 hours the engine and all the pumps stopped.

The satellite phone Sikander had provided did not work, so they could not make distress calls.

About 2am the next day, the boat sank ”in two or three minutes”.

The asylum seekers, most of whom had life preservers, grabbed one of two ropes to keep them together. Habib was with 25 others clinging to one

rope, the remaining eight were on the second rope. ”On the first day there was hope. Everyone was optimistic,” Mr Ullah says. ”We were praying, saying, ‘There will be an island, there will be a boat.’

”On the second day, some people, they lost control, shouting and crying, saying, ‘No one will help us.’

”Then time was passing, night was coming, and the day passing, losing friends. I would see dead bodies coming from the right side, left side. Everyone, one by one, was waiting for their turn.

”Some guys got crazy, they were talking and fighting, they let go of the rope and went away. On the third night there were seven people on the rope. I was very tired and went to sleep. In the morning, there were only three people left, including me. Those guys, their health condition was really bad … one was trying to drown because he was very thirsty and he was very hungry. So he drowned before my eyes.

”On the third day, after they had all died, I was on the ocean from morning to 3pm. I was exhausted, thirsty, tired, hot, pain in my stomach, pain in my kidneys, there was fear of storm, fear of sharks. And, I think, it was the last moment of my life when the boat came to me.”

Mr Ullah was picked up by a large Indonesian fishing boat south of the island of Panaitan, and nursed to health by the crew before being moved to a second fishing boat, which took him to Jakarta. He is now in the Kuningan immigration detention centre in Jakarta, plagued by memories.

”It’s very horrifying for me. When I go to sleep I just remember,” he says.

One of the many who have visited him to ask for news of relatives is Australian resident Reza Shafaie, who came to Indonesia to find his cousin, Ali Noori, 17, and uncle, Ali Barati.

Mr Shafaie now believes both died in the sinking, although other families in Australia are not yet convinced.

”They really cry, but they told us to keep searching those areas. They say, ‘Maybe there is an island.’ Still they have hope.”

Muhammad Rezaie, of Dandenong, also came to Jakarta to search for loved ones, but he has given up hope for nephew Enayatullah Hussaini and friends Taqi Bahadori and Mohammad Jawad. Mr Rezaie, who came to Australia by boat in 2001, said he had begged his nephew not to take the risk, saying he should wait for a visa in Indonesia.

”I told him, ‘The rules have changed, they’ll send you to Nauru.’ But he didn’t listen because his friends push him – ‘Let’s go together.’ The people smuggler was also pushing,” Mr Rezaie said.

Mr Ullah, Mr Rezaie and Mr Shafaie have all spoken to people smuggler Sikander by phone. At first, they say, he denied Mr Ullah’s story, saying the boat was safe on Christmas Island. He later admitted it had sunk.

Mr Rezaie and Mr Shafaie say Sikander is still active as a people smuggler and sent three more boats in past weeks carrying a total of 311 asylum seekers to Christmas Island. Mr Ullah wants to see him prosecuted.



Filed under Boat Tragedy

4 responses to “Boat tragedy claims 33 asylum seekers

  1. Hashim

    Indonesian Police and Army is Corrupt. They will held them in prison but at out said they are on their duties. Law enforcement agencies not only must take action about Sikander but his remaining friends who are working as a team in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Indonesia. Some of Smugglers are still working in these regions openly. Because they pay their Money (Bribe) to their Countries F.I.A and other police or Immigration Departments. A big and effective action must be taken to Stop this sort of deadly journies.

  2. Salam habib .l am brother of one who was with u in the boat with u. I want ur personal email or Please. My email adress is saeed_85afg

    Send me a message

  3. Pingback: Karobare ghairi qanoni Baradarani Froghi ba Enwani Qachaqbari mardum faash Gardid

  4. Pingback: Photo Album | Boat Tragedy (October 26, 2012) | Hazara Asylum Seekers

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s